Option (A) is correct.
Explanation:
Reason is true. NCERT: "humans derive countless direct economic benefits from nature- food (cereals, pulses, fruits), firewood, fibre, construction material, industrial products (tannins, lubricants, dyes, resins, perfumes ) and products of medicinal importance."
Assertion is true, and R explains it. Pulses are food and timber is construction material, and both appear by name in R's list. Both are direct benefits: products that people use or sell. That is exactly what the narrowly utilitarian argument is about.
Being cultivated does not take the pulses out of this argument. A crop is still a species from nature. Its varieties are part of biodiversity at the genetic level, just as NCERT counts India's "more than 50,000 genetically different strains of rice".
| Benefit | Kind | Argument |
|---|
| pulses (food) | direct product | narrowly utilitarian |
| timber (construction material) | direct product | narrowly utilitarian |
| pollination, pest control, flood control | ecosystem services | broadly utilitarian |
Because both examples come straight from R's list of direct benefits, R is the correct explanation of A.
Why the other options are wrong
- (B) R does explain A: pulses (food) and construction material are both in R's list of direct economic benefits, which is the narrowly utilitarian argument.
- (C) R is true: it is NCERT's own list of the direct economic benefits humans derive from nature.
- (D) A is true: a cultivated crop is still a direct benefit from nature, so it falls under the narrowly utilitarian argument.