(a) Greenland. Humboldt observed that "within a region species richness increased with increasing explored area, but only up to a limit". Greenland is about 15 times as large as New York state, so on area alone it should hold more bird species.
(b) Greenland has fewer bird species (56 against 105), roughly half as many, despite being much larger. Something that changes with latitude must outweigh the effect of area. That is the latitudinal gradient: "species diversity decreases as we move away from the equator towards the poles." Greenland lies 30 degrees farther from the equator than New York.
(c) A difference in area and a difference in latitude can each change the number of species. The question is which way each one pushes.
| Comparison | Area favours | Latitude favours | Observed | Strength of evidence |
|---|
| Greenland against New York | Greenland (larger) | New York (lower latitude) | New York richer | strong: latitude wins against the area effect |
| a larger place at low latitude against a smaller place at high latitude (hypothetical) | the low-latitude place | the low-latitude place | low-latitude place richer | weak: area alone could explain the result |
In the Greenland case the two effects work against each other, and latitude still wins. So area cannot be the explanation. In the second case both effects push the same way, so we cannot tell which one caused the difference. This is also why NCERT's own comparison of Ecuador with the Midwest of the USA uses forests "of equal area".
(d) Any one, applied to Greenland:
- Evolutionary time: "Speciation is generally a function of time". NCERT contrasts tropical latitudes, which "have remained relatively undisturbed for millions of years", with temperate regions "subjected to frequent glaciations in the past". Greenland, farther from the equator still, is likely to have had even less undisturbed time for species to diversify.
- Constant environment: tropical environments "are less seasonal, relatively more constant and predictable". At 71° N, the environment is strongly seasonal, which gives less scope for the niche specialisation that leads to greater species diversity.
- Solar energy: "There is more solar energy available in the tropics". Greenland receives much less, so productivity is lower, and this might indirectly support fewer species.
