Confirming your payment

Skip to content

Practice Questions · Question 10 of 30

Two statements in NCERT both link productivity and diversity: Statement 1 (tropics): there is more solar energy in the…

Question 103 marksHard

Two statements in NCERT both link productivity and diversity:

  • Statement 1 (tropics): there is more solar energy in the tropics, "which contributes to higher productivity; this in turn might contribute indirectly to greater diversity."
  • Statement 2 (Tilman): "in his experiments, increased diversity contributed to higher productivity."

(a) Write each statement as a chain of cause and effect using arrows. (1)

(b) A student says the two statements contradict each other, so one of them must be wrong. Evaluate this claim. (1)

(c) Suppose Tilman's outdoor plots were sown by the experimenters with different numbers of species, and were otherwise alike in soil, water and light. Explain why this design lets him conclude that diversity affects productivity, rather than the other way round. (1)