NCERT: "Biopiracy is the term used to refer to the use of bio-resources by multinational companies and other organisations without proper authorisation from the countries and people concerned without compensatory payment."
| Part of the definition | What it says |
|---|
| Who | multinational companies and other organisations |
| What | use of bio-resources |
| Condition 1 | without proper authorisation from the countries and the people concerned |
| Condition 2 | without compensatory payment |
Student 1: A patent is not biopiracy in itself. The use of bio-resources becomes biopiracy only when it is done without proper authorisation and without compensatory payment. A company that has permission and pays for the resource is not committing biopiracy, even if it patents its product.
Student 2: The definition names "multinational companies and other organisations", so any organisation can commit biopiracy, not only a foreign multinational.
Student 3: Authorisation is needed from "the countries and people concerned", not only from the government, and compensatory payment is also required. Using the community's plant and knowledge without asking or paying them is still biopiracy.