In 1997, an American company obtained patent rights on Basmati rice through the US Patent and Trademark Office and began selling a "new" variety of Basmati. Why did this claim of a new invention cause public anger in India?
Practice Questions · Question 4 of 30
In 1997, an American company obtained patent rights on Basmati rice through the US Patent and Trademark Office and…
(A) The "new" variety had been produced by genetic engineering of Indian Basmati, and GEAC had not approved its release for public use in India.
(B) The patent covered all 27 documented varieties of Basmati, so Indian farmers would have had to stop growing their own traditional varieties.
- Correct answer
(C) The "new" variety had been derived from Indian farmers' varieties, by crossing Indian Basmati with semi-dwarf varieties, yet it was claimed as a novelty.
(D) The patent was granted by the Indian Patent Office to a foreign company, although Basmati is mentioned in India's ancient texts, folklore and poetry.
Option (C) is correct.
Explanation: India has an estimated 200,000 rice varieties, 27 documented varieties of Basmati, and references to Basmati in ancient texts, folklore and poetry. The "new" variety had been derived from Indian farmers' varieties. NCERT: "Indian Basmati was crossed with semi-dwarf varieties and claimed as an invention or a novelty." A product built on bio-resources that farmers had developed and used for centuries was patented as if it were new. This is the kind of use NCERT calls biopiracy.
- (A) NCERT describes a cross with semi-dwarf varieties, not genetic engineering, and GEAC plays no part in this case.
- (B) NCERT does not say the patent covered the 27 varieties or stopped Indian farmers from growing them.
- (D) The patent was granted by the US Patent and Trademark Office, not by India.
