A dry steel needle laid gently on the surface of clean water stays on the surface, even though steel is much denser than water. When a drop of detergent is added to the water, the needle sinks. Explain both observations.
Practice Questions · Question 25 of 37
A dry steel needle laid gently on the surface of clean water stays on the surface, even though steel is much denser…
Why the needle stays on the surface: The needle presses the water surface down slightly, making a shallow trough. The water surface behaves like a stretched membrane: along each line of contact with the needle, surface tension pulls on the needle with a force per unit length, directed along the curved water surface. On the two sides of the needle these forces slope upward, so their vertical components add up and support the needle's weight.

For a needle of length , each side gives a force , and the needle sinks into the surface until the upward components of these forces balance its weight .
Why it sinks with detergent: Detergent lowers the surface tension of the water. The surface-tension forces become too small to hold up the weight, even when the surface is depressed as far as it can be, so the needle breaks through the surface and sinks.
