A proton is kept at rest. A positively charged particle is released from rest at a distance in its field. Consider two experiments: one in which the charged particle is also a proton, and another in which it is a positron. In the same time , the work done on the two moving charged particles is
Practice Questions · Question 13 of 37
A proton is kept at rest.
(A) the same, as the same force law is involved in the two experiments
(B) less for the case of a positron, as the positron moves away more rapidly and the force on it weakens
- Correct answer
(C) more for the case of a positron, as the positron moves away a larger distance
(D) the same as the work done by the charged particle on the stationary proton
Option (C) is correct.
Explanation: A proton and a positron have the same charge , so at the same separation the repulsive force from the fixed proton is the same on both. The positron's mass is about of the proton's mass, so its acceleration is far larger. In the same time the positron therefore moves through a much larger distance.
The work done on the particle is over the distance it covers. The force is repulsive and in the direction of motion all along, so a larger distance means more work. The force does weaken as the separation grows, but it never reverses, so every extra bit of distance adds positive work. Hence the work done on the positron in time is greater. (Equivalently, by the work–energy theorem, the positron gains more kinetic energy in that time.)
(A) is wrong: the same force law does not give the same work, because the two particles cover different distances in the same time.
(B) is wrong: the force on the positron weakens, but it still acts along its motion over a much larger distance, so the work is larger, not smaller.
(D) is wrong: the stationary proton does not move, so the work done on it is zero, whereas the work done on the moving particle is positive.
