A bird is sitting in a wire cage that hangs from a spring balance. The reading of the spring balance is . The bird now flies about inside the cage, and the reading becomes . Which of the following is true?
Practice Questions · Question 12 of 38
A bird is sitting in a wire cage that hangs from a spring balance.
- Correct answer
(A)
(B)
(C)
(D) Nothing can be said about and
Option (A) is correct.
Explanation: When the bird sits on the perch, it presses down on the cage with a force equal to its weight. The spring balance supports the cage and the bird, so
When the bird flies, it no longer touches the cage. It stays up by pushing air downward with its wings; by Newton's third law the air pushes the bird upward. The bird's weight is now carried by the air that it pushes down.
In a wire cage the walls and floor are open mesh. The air pushed down by the wings flows out through the wires into the surroundings instead of pressing on the cage floor. So the force that supports the bird is not passed on to the cage, and the balance reads essentially the weight of the cage alone:
(This is different from a closed, air-tight box. There the downward-moving air would push on the floor of the box, and on average the balance would still read the total weight.)
(B) could exceed only if something pushed down on the cage harder than the bird's weight, which does not happen here.
(C) would be true only if the air pushed down by the wings pressed on the cage floor, as in a closed box, not an open wire cage.
(D) The comparison can be made definitely, as shown above.
