An inventor claims to have designed a ship that powers itself by taking heat from the sea water around it and converting all of this heat into work to drive its propellers. The cooled water is left behind. Such a ship would not violate the principle of conservation of energy. Explain why it is nevertheless impossible.
Practice Questions · Question 22 of 37
An inventor claims to have designed a ship that powers itself by taking heat from the sea water around it and…
The claim does satisfy the first law: the energy that drives the ship would be exactly equal to the heat taken from the ocean, so no energy is created.
It violates the second law of thermodynamics. The ship takes heat from a single reservoir (the ocean, all at one temperature) and converts the whole of it into work, with no other effect. The Kelvin–Planck statement says that no process is possible whose sole result is the absorption of heat from a reservoir and the complete conversion of the heat into work.
To get work from heat, an engine must take heat from a hotter body and give out part of it, , to a colder body; only the difference can become work. The ship has no colder body to reject heat to, since the surrounding sea is all at the same temperature, so it cannot run.
