Which one of the following processes is reversible (in the idealised sense used in thermodynamics)?
Practice Questions · Question 13 of 37
Which one of the following processes is reversible (in the idealised sense used in thermodynamics)?
(A) Free expansion of a gas from a cylinder into an evacuated vessel
(B) Flow of heat from a hot metal block to a cold one placed in contact with it
(C) Stirring of a liquid by a paddle, which warms the liquid
- Correct answer
(D) Very slow (quasi-static) isothermal expansion of an ideal gas in a cylinder fitted with a frictionless piston
Option (D) is correct.
Explanation: A process is reversible if it can be turned back so that both the system and the surroundings return to their original states, with no other change anywhere. This needs two things: the process must be quasi-static (the system is in equilibrium with its surroundings at every stage) and there must be no dissipative effects such as friction. A very slow isothermal expansion of an ideal gas against a frictionless piston satisfies both, so a tiny change in the external pressure can reverse it at any stage.
- (A) Free expansion takes the gas through non-equilibrium states; the gas never goes back into the cylinder by itself.
- (B) Heat flows across a finite temperature difference; it never flows back by itself from the cold block to the hot one.
- (C) Stirring is a dissipative process; the warm liquid cannot turn its internal energy back into the work done by the paddle.
