The frequency of vibration of a stretched string depends on its length l , the tension F in it and its mass per unit…
Question 335 marksHard
The frequency ν of vibration of a stretched string depends on its length l, the tension F in it and its mass per unit length μ.
(a) Using the method of dimensions, deduce the relation for ν.
(b) By what factor does the frequency change if the tension is made four times, all else unchanged?
(c) State one limitation of the method that shows up in this result.
(a) Let ν=klaFbμc, where k is a dimensionless constant. The dimensions are [ν]=[T−1], [l]=[L], [F]=[MLT−2] and [μ]=[ML−1].
[M0L0T−1]=[L]a[MLT−2]b[ML−1]c=[Mb+cLa+b−cT−2b]
Equating the powers:
T: −2b=−1, so b=21
M: b+c=0, so c=−21
L: a+b−c=0, so a=−1
ν=lkμF
(b)ν∝F. Making F four times multiplies ν by 4=2, so the frequency doubles.
(c) The method cannot give the value of the dimensionless constant k. For the lowest (fundamental) frequency, experiment gives k=21, and for higher modes k takes other values. Dimensional analysis cannot tell these apart.