(a) Let the oxidation number of Mn be x. Oxygen is −2 and the compound is neutral:
3x+4(−2)=0⇒x=+38≈+2.67
(b) In MnO: x−2=0, so Mn is +2. In Mn2O3: 2x−6=0, so each Mn is +3. One formula unit of Mn3O4 therefore contains one Mn(II) and two Mn(III):
average=3(+2)+2(+3)=+38
This is the same value as in (a), so the formula method gives only the average.
(c) An electron cannot be split. The value +38 is an average over three manganese atoms that are actually in two different whole-number states, +2 and +3. When the same element sits in two different bonding situations in one compound, the formula method gives only an average, which is often fractional (though not always: for N in NH4NO3 the average of −3 and +5 is +1); the structure is needed to find the real oxidation state of each atom.