Count the electrons around the central atom in each of the following species and state which limitation of the octet rule each illustrates:
(a) ClO₂ (chlorine dioxide, central Cl)
(b) AlCl₃ (as a single gaseous molecule)
(c) XeF₂
Confirming your payment
Practice Questions · Question 19 of 37
Count the electrons around the central atom in each of the following species and state which limitation of the octet rule each illustrates:
(a) ClO₂ (chlorine dioxide, central Cl)
(b) AlCl₃ (as a single gaseous molecule)
(c) XeF₂
(a) ClO₂ — odd-electron molecule. Total valence electrons = 7 (Cl) + 2 × 6 (O) = 19. An odd number of electrons can never all be paired, so at least one atom (here chlorine) cannot have a complete octet. The octet rule cannot account for such molecules.
(b) AlCl₃ — incomplete octet. Aluminium has 3 valence electrons and forms three Al–Cl single bonds. It is surrounded by only three shared pairs, i.e. 6 electrons, fewer than an octet, yet the molecule exists.
(c) XeF₂ — expanded octet, and a noble gas forming a compound. Xenon has 8 valence electrons; two are used in the two Xe–F bonds and six remain as three lone pairs. Xenon is therefore surrounded by 2 bond pairs + 3 lone pairs = 10 electrons, more than an octet (possible because Xe has vacant 5d orbitals). It also shows the further drawback that the octet rule, based on the inertness of noble gases, cannot explain why xenon forms compounds at all.