(i) The four set-ups and their results:
- Set-up a: the coleoptile was left intact. It bent towards the light.
- Set-up b: the tip of the coleoptile was cut off. It grew straight and did not bend.
- Set-up c: the tip was covered with an opaque cap, so no light reached it. It did not bend.
- Set-up d: the lower part was enclosed in a shield while the tip was left exposed to the light. It bent towards the light.
(ii) Set-ups a and b. The intact coleoptile bends towards the light, but a coleoptile whose tip has been cut off does not bend at all.
(iii) Set-ups c and d. In c the lower part is in the light but the tip is covered, and there is no bending; in d the lower part is shielded but the tip is exposed, and the coleoptile bends. So the light must reach the tip.
(iv) The response is phototropism, growth towards a unilateral light source. The Darwins concluded that the tip of the coleoptile was the site of a transmittable influence that caused the bending of the entire coleoptile. (This substance, auxin, was later isolated by F.W. Went from tips of coleoptiles of oat seedlings.)