The Moon is far closer to us than any star, yet stars twinkle and the Moon does not.
(a) Explain the difference.
(b) An astronaut standing on the Moon looks at those same stars. Would they twinkle? Give a reason.
Confirming your payment
Practice Questions · Question 26 of 30
The Moon is far closer to us than any star, yet stars twinkle and the Moon does not.
(a) Explain the difference.
(b) An astronaut standing on the Moon looks at those same stars. Would they twinkle? Give a reason.
(a) It is not the distance that matters but the apparent size.
A star is so far away that, however large it really is, it reaches us as a point source of light. All its light arrives along essentially one path, and as the restless layers of the atmosphere shift, that single path is bent now a little this way and now a little that. The amount of light entering the eye rises and falls from moment to moment, and the star's apparent position wavers — which we see as twinkling.
The Moon is close enough to appear as an extended object, a disc of measurable width. Think of it as an enormous number of point sources side by side. Each one twinkles, but they do so independently — at any instant some are momentarily brighter and others dimmer, and across the whole disc these variations average out. The total light reaching the eye stays steady, so the Moon shines with a constant light.
The same reasoning explains why planets do not twinkle: they too are near enough to present a small disc rather than a point.
(b) No — they would shine perfectly steadily.
Twinkling is not something stars do; it is something the atmosphere does to their light. The Moon has no atmosphere, so there are no layers of moving air to bend the light this way and that on its way to the astronaut's eye. Every star would hold a fixed position and a constant brightness, however point-like it was.
This is also why telescopes are placed on high mountains, where there is less air above them, and why a telescope in orbit sees stars that do not twinkle at all.