Option (C) is correct.
Step 1 — write the roots. Since q2−4pr>0, the roots are real and distinct:
x=2p−q+Dandx=2p−q−D,D=q2−4pr
Step 2 — suppose p, q and r are all positive. Then 4pr>0, so
D=q2−4pr<q2⇒D<q
Step 3 — look at the signs of the numerators.
- −q+D is negative, because D is smaller than q.
- −q−D is negative, because both terms are negative.
Dividing by the positive number 2p keeps both roots negative.
Example: x2+3x+2=0 has p,q,r>0 and roots −1 and −2 — both negative.
So Suman is right. Zain is wrong (the roots need not be positive — x2+3x+2=0 is a counter-example), and Vipul's claim is the opposite of the truth.
(C) Suman