International A-series paper sizes (A3, A4, A5, …) are designed so that the length is 2 times the breadth. Folding such a sheet in half across its length gives the next size, with exactly the same shape. An A4 sheet is sold as 297 mm long and 210 mm wide.
(i) Using prime factorisation, write the ratio 297:210 in its simplest form. [1]
(ii) A student says, "A 297 mm by 210 mm sheet is exactly in the ratio 2:1." Is the student right? Give a reason. [1]
(iii) Given that 2 is irrational, show that if a sheet's length is exactly2 times its breadth, then its length and breadth cannot both be whole numbers of millimetres. [2]
OR
(iii) For a sheet whose length is exactly 2 times its breadth b, the diagonal is 3b. Prove that 3 is irrational, and hence that the diagonal and the breadth of such a sheet cannot both be whole numbers of millimetres. [2]
(i) Simplest form of 297:210.
297=33×11,210=2×3×5×7
The only common prime is 3, so HCF(297,210)=3:
297:210=99:70
(ii) Is the student right?
No.7099 is a ratio of two integers, so it is rational, while 2 is irrational. A rational number can never equal an irrational one.
(7099)2=49009801,2=49009800
The two are very close but not equal: the printed size is a rounded approximation.
(iii) Length and breadth cannot both be whole numbers.
Suppose, to the contrary, that the breadth b and the length l are both whole numbers of millimetres, with b=0 and l=2b. Then
2=bl
is a ratio of two integers — a rational number. This contradicts the fact that 2 is irrational.
So at least one of the length and the breadth is not a whole number of millimetres.
OR (iii) 3 is irrational, and its consequence.
Assume, to the contrary, that 3=ba, where a and b are integers, b=0, with no common factor other than 1. Then
3b2=a2
So 3 divides a2, and since 3 is prime, 3 divides a. Put a=3c:
3b2=9c2⇒b2=3c2
So 3 divides b as well — contradicting that a and b have no common factor. Hence 3 is irrational.
Consequence. If the diagonal d=3b and the breadth b were both whole numbers, then 3=bd would be rational — impossible. So they cannot both be whole numbers.