Magnesium ribbon gives bubbles of hydrogen with dilute hydrochloric acid, but powdered sulphur and pieces of charcoal (carbon) give no hydrogen at all. Non-metals do not displace hydrogen from dilute acids because:
Practice Questions · Question 20 of 30
Magnesium ribbon gives bubbles of hydrogen with dilute hydrochloric acid, but powdered sulphur and pieces of charcoal…
(A) they form a protective oxide layer that stops the reaction
(B) they are insoluble in water, so they never come into contact with the acid
(C) they are placed below copper in the reactivity series
- Correct answer
(D) they cannot supply electrons to the hydrogen ions of the acid, since they gain or share electrons instead of losing them
Option (D) is correct.
Explanation: When a metal such as magnesium reacts with a dilute acid, the metal atoms lose electrons and these electrons are taken up by the hydrogen ions () of the acid, which then form hydrogen gas. A substance can displace hydrogen from an acid only if it is able to give electrons to the ions.
Non-metals do not lose electrons. They have four to seven electrons in their outermost shell and complete their octet either by gaining electrons, as chlorine and sulphur do when they form and with metals, or by sharing electrons, as carbon does in its compounds. With no tendency to give electrons away, they cannot change into hydrogen gas, so non-metals do not displace hydrogen from dilute acids.
Option (A) is wrong: a protective oxide layer is a property of some metals, such as aluminium, which only delays their reaction; it is not why non-metals fail to give hydrogen.
Option (B) is wrong: being insoluble does not stop a reaction; zinc and iron are insoluble in water too, yet they react with dilute acids and give hydrogen.
Option (C) is wrong: the reactivity series is a list of metals (with hydrogen as a reference point); sulphur and carbon are not placed in it below copper, so this cannot be the reason.

A metal above hydrogen gives hydrogen with a dilute acid; a non-metal does not.
