A student is asked to balance
and writes , saying that the oxygen atoms now balance.
(a) Explain why this is not allowed.
(b) Give the correct balanced equation.
Confirming your payment
Practice Questions · Question 28 of 30
A student is asked to balance
and writes , saying that the oxygen atoms now balance.
(a) Explain why this is not allowed.
(b) Give the correct balanced equation.
(a) Because the student has changed a formula, not a coefficient.
The small numbers written inside a formula — the subscripts — state what the substance is. is water; is hydrogen peroxide, an entirely different compound that bleaches hair and kills bacteria.
Be clear about what is and is not wrong here. As written, the student's equation does have equal numbers of atoms on each side — that is precisely what makes the mistake tempting. The objection is that it is no longer the same reaction: it now describes hydrogen burning to give hydrogen peroxide, which is not what happens and not what was asked. A balanced equation for the wrong reaction is of no use at all.
Balancing means adjusting only the large numbers in front of the formulae, which say how many of each substance take part. Those you may change freely; the formulae themselves are fixed by the substances involved and must be left exactly as they are.
(b)
Hydrogen 4 and 4; oxygen 2 and 2 — and the product really is water.