(a) Because a disposable item is designed to be used once, and the resources that went into making it — material, water, energy, transport — are spent for that single use.
Being biodegradable means it will eventually rot away, which is better than plastic. But it does not recover the resources used to make it, and the sheer quantity still has to be collected and treated. A hundred biodegradable cups a day is still a hundred cups a day.
(b) Reduce.
Recycle cannot help much, since these items are thrown away dirty and are rarely worth recycling. Reuse is defeated by the design — they are made to be discarded.
Reduce addresses the problem at its root: an item not used at all needs no treatment, produces no waste, and consumes no resources. Using ordinary plates and washing them solves the whole problem at once.
This is why the three Rs are given in that order. Reducing is always the most effective, and recycling — though the one most talked about — is the last resort of the three.