(i) Are there points X, Y on the circle, on the same side of AB, such that ∠AXB is different from ∠AYB?
Answer: No.
Reason: If X and Y lie on the same side of chord AB, then they lie on the same arc AB. Angles subtended by the same chord in the same segment of a circle are equal. Therefore, ∠AXB=∠AYB
So, there are no such points X and Y on the same side of AB for which the angles are different.
(ii) Is it true that if ∠AXB=∠AYB, then X and Y lie on the same side of the circle?
Answer: Not necessarily.
Reason: Suppose X and Y lie on the circle on opposite sides of AB. Then AXBY is a cyclic quadrilateral, so its opposite angles add up to 180° (Theorem 11):
∠AXB+∠AYB=180°
So ∠AXB=∠AYB is possible on opposite sides only when both angles are 90°, that is, when AB is a diameter.
Hence, if AB is a diameter, X and Y can lie on opposite sides of AB with ∠AXB=∠AYB (both 90°), so the statement is not true in general. If AB is not a diameter, equal angles do force X and Y to lie on the same side of AB.
(iii) If ∠AXB=∠AYB, and X and Y do not lie on the circle, does the circle through A, B and X also pass through Y?
Answer: Yes, provided X and Y lie on the same side of AB.
Reason: If ∠AXB=∠AYB and X, Y lie on the same side of AB, then by Theorem 10 (a segment that subtends equal angles at two points on the same side of it) the four points A, B, X and Y lie on a circle. There is only one circle through A, B and X (Theorem 1), so the circle through A, B and X also passes through Y.
If X and Y lie on opposite sides of AB, the answer is no in general. For example, take Y to be the mirror image of X in the line AB. Then ∠AYB=∠AXB, but Y lies on the mirror image of the circle through A, B and X, not on that circle itself (unless AB is a diameter of it).