(Challenge) Give the dimension of a cuboid whose volume is halved when its surface area is doubled.
Math of Space: Surface Area and Volume · Question 51 of 52
(Challenge) Give the dimension of a cuboid whose volume is halved when its surface area is doubled.
What the question means. A cuboid's volume and surface area are fixed by its dimensions, so they can change only when the dimensions change. We read the question as: find a cuboid that can be changed into a new cuboid whose surface area is double the original and whose volume is half the original. More surface with less volume means the new cuboid must be much flatter (thinner).
Simple changes do not work.
- Enlarging every edge by the same factor multiplies the surface area by and the volume by . Doubling the surface area needs , which multiplies the volume by — the volume grows instead of halving.
- Halving just one edge (say ) halves the volume, but the surface area becomes smaller, not double.
Flatten it. Double the length and the width, and cut the height to one-eighth: . The volume becomes
so it is always halved. For the surface area to double we need
Choosing a square base gives .
A cuboid that works: 14 cm × 14 cm × 8 cm, flattened into a cuboid of 28 cm × 28 cm × 1 cm.
Check:
| Original: 14 × 14 × 8 | New: 28 × 28 × 1 | |
|---|---|---|
| Volume | ||
| Surface area |
, so the volume is halved, and , so the surface area is doubled.
The answer is not unique: any cuboid with works with the same change, and other flattening changes give other examples (for instance 8 cm × 10 cm × 24 cm can be reshaped into 1 cm × 24 cm × 40 cm, with volume and surface area ).
