Draw a non-convex 4-gon DART. Show how we can tile the plane with copies of DART. Both methods that we discussed earlier will work. Which do you prefer?
Quadrilaterals · Question 16 of 40
Draw a non-convex 4-gon DART.
The 4-gon. Take D(1.5, 1.2), A(0, 0), R(3.4, 0.4), T(1, 3). D lies inside , so DART has a dent at D: its internal angle at D is reflex (about ), and the other angles are about at A, at R and at T. They add up to .

Method 1 (half-turns about midpoints of sides). Cut out many copies of DART. Place a second copy by turning DART through about the midpoint of one side, say DA. The half-turn swaps D and A, so the new copy fits exactly along DA. Repeat this at every side of every copy you add.
Why it works: around each vertex of the pattern, four copies meet, and they bring the four different angles , , , , one each. These add up to (even though is reflex), so they close up around the point with no gap and no overlap. Two half-turns about the midpoints of neighbouring sides amount to a slide (translation) along a diagonal, so the upright copies are DART shifted along the diagonals DR and AT, and the turned copies are shifted in the same way. The result is the tiling below (the original DART is darker; upright copies in one colour, half-turned copies in the other).

Method 2 (Varignon grid). Join the midpoints of the sides of DART to get its Varignon parallelogram (Theorem 9). First draw the grid tiling of the plane by copies of this parallelogram, and think of the grid as a chessboard. Every copy of DART will sit on a parallelogram of one colour: the midpoints of its four sides are the four corners of that parallelogram. Place copies of DART on some parallelograms of this colour, exactly as in Exercise Set 12.3, Q5 (neighbouring copies are alternately upright and half-turned). The copies meet each other exactly at vertices, and the gaps left between them are automatically copies of DART, which we then fill in. The parallelograms of the other colour are centred at the vertices of the tiling. The dashed lines below show the Varignon parallelograms of all the tiles: together with the gaps between them they form a parallelogram grid.

Which do you prefer? (Sample answer.) For actually laying out cut-out pieces, Method 1 is simpler: there is only one rule, ‘turn a copy through about the midpoint of a side’, and each new piece is checked against one neighbour. Method 2 is better for explaining why the tiling never runs into trouble, because the parallelogram grid fixes the position of every copy in advance and shows that the pattern repeats in two directions. Both methods give the same tiling, and both work for a non-convex 4-gon like DART.
