The following questions examine converses of true properties.
Question 84 marksMedium
The following questions examine converses of true properties. Answer them with Yes or No. If your answer is No, what extra condition can you add so that the answer becomes Yes?
(i) If the diagonals of a quadrilateral ABCD bisect its angles, must ABCD be a rhombus?
(ii) If the diagonals of a quadrilateral ABCD bisect each other at right angles, must ABCD be a rhombus?
(iii) If the diagonals of a quadrilateral ABCD are of equal length, must ABCD be a rectangle? (In the ancient Indian study of quadrilaterals, equality of diagonals was considered significant. Quadrilaterals were first classified according to whether their diagonals were equal or not, before considering equality of sides.)
(i) Yes. Suppose AC bisects ∠A and ∠C, and BD bisects ∠B and ∠D.
In △ABC and △ADC: ∠BAC=∠DAC, AC is common, and ∠BCA=∠DCA. So △ABC≅△ADC (ASA), giving AB=AD and CB=CD.
In △ABD and △CBD: ∠ABD=∠CBD, BD is common, and ∠ADB=∠CDB. So △ABD≅△CBD (ASA), giving AB=CB and AD=CD.
Together, AB=BC=CD=DA, so ABCD must be a rhombus.
(ii) Yes. Let the diagonals meet at E, with EA=EC, EB=ED and ∠AEB=90∘.
Since the diagonals bisect each other, ABCD is a parallelogram (Theorem 4). In △AEB and △AED: AE is common, EB=ED and ∠AEB=∠AED=90∘. So △AEB≅△AED (SAS) and AB=AD.
In the parallelogram, AB=CD and AD=BC, so all four sides are equal: ABCD must be a rhombus.
(iii) No. Counterexample: the isosceles trapezium A(0, 0), B(6, 0), C(4, 3), D(2, 3). Its diagonals are equal:
AC=42+32=5,BD=(6−2)2+32=5,
but it is not a rectangle (AB=6 while DC=2, and ∠A=90∘). A kite-like shape can also have equal diagonals without being a rectangle.
Extra condition: the diagonals also bisect each other. Then ABCD is a parallelogram (Theorem 4) with equal diagonals, and by Q1 (iii) it is a rectangle. So: if the diagonals of a quadrilateral are equal and bisect each other, it must be a rectangle.