Assertion (A): 2 g of hydrogen combines with 16 g of oxygen to form 18 g of water.
Reason (R): According to Dalton's Atomic Theory, atoms combine in a simple whole number ratio by mass to form compounds.
Choose the correct option.
Confirming your payment
Atomic Foundations of Matter · Question 10 of 42
Assertion (A): 2 g of hydrogen combines with 16 g of oxygen to form 18 g of water.
Reason (R): According to Dalton's Atomic Theory, atoms combine in a simple whole number ratio by mass to form compounds.
Choose the correct option.
(A) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
(B) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
(C) A is true, but R is false.
(D) A is false, but R is true.
Option (C) is correct.
Assertion (A) is true. 2 g + 16 g = 18 g, so the mass of water formed equals the total mass of hydrogen and oxygen that combined (Law of Conservation of Mass). The two elements are also in the mass ratio 2 : 16 = 1 : 8, the fixed ratio the chapter gives for water.
Reason (R) is false. Dalton's postulate, as the book states it, is that atoms combine in the ratio of simple whole numbers to form compounds, and that the relative number and kinds of atoms are constant in a compound. The whole-number ratio is a ratio of numbers of atoms, not of masses. The masses of combining elements need not be in a simple whole-number ratio: the book's Example 9.3 gives sodium and chlorine in sodium chloride in the mass ratio 23 : 35.5, although they combine one atom to one atom (NaCl). Adding "by mass" turns the postulate into a false statement.
Why the other options are wrong