The two cuts must be perpendicular and must both pass through the centre O of the square, as in the figure. Then the four pieces are identical: turning the square through a right angle about O carries each piece onto the next one.
Each piece has a right angle at O, and the two edges that meet at O are each half of a cut, so they are equal.
Rearranging: slide the four pieces outward, without turning them, until the four right-angle corners that were at O become the four corners of a new square. Along each side of the new square, a half-cut of one piece lines up with a half-cut of the next piece, so each side of the new square is as long as one whole cut.
The old corners of the square now point inward, and they leave a square hole in the middle.

Why the new square is larger: a cut that slants across the square is longer than the side of the square. The four pieces still have the same total area as the old square, so
Area of new square = Area of old square + Area of the hole.
For example, take a square of side 4 cm whose cuts meet each side 1 cm from one corner and 3 cm from the other. The hole is a square of side 3−1=2 cm, and the new square has area 16+4=20 cm².