Is it necessary to construct the pairs of arcs above and below XY? Instead, can we construct both the pairs of arcs on the same side of XY? Explore this through construction, and then justify your answer.
Constructions and Tilings · Question 2 of 25
Is it necessary to construct the pairs of arcs above and below XY?

No, it is not necessary. Both pairs of arcs can be drawn on the same side of XY, as long as the two pairs use different radii.
Construction:
(i) Draw a line segment XY.
(ii) With centres X and Y and radius x, draw two arcs above XY. Mark the point where they meet as A.
(iii) With centres X and Y and a different radius y (smaller than x), draw two more arcs above XY. Mark the point where they meet as B.
(iv) Join A and B and extend the line to meet XY at O.
Justification:
AX = AY = x, so A is at the same distance from X and Y. BX = BY = y, so B is also at the same distance from X and Y. Both A and B lie on the perpendicular bisector of XY, and two points fix a line. So line AB is the perpendicular bisector of XY.
We can check it with congruence. In and : AX = AY, BX = BY and AB is common, so the triangles are congruent (SSS) and . In and : AX = AY, and AO is common, so they are congruent (SAS). Hence OX = OY and . These two angles together make , so each is .
Note: if the same radius were used for both pairs, the arcs would meet at the same point (A and B would coincide) and we would get only one point, which is not enough to draw the line. That is why the two radii must be different.
