What do you think of Raman’s statement, “All starches are carbohydrates but not all carbohydrates are starches.” Describe the design of an activity to test your answer.
Mindful Eating: A Path to a Healthy Body · Question 10 of 13
What do you think of Raman’s statement, “All starches are carbohydrates but not all carbohydrates are starches.”…
My view: Raman's statement is correct. Starch is a type of carbohydrate, so all starches are carbohydrates. But there are other carbohydrates too, such as common sugar and glucose, which are not starch. So not all carbohydrates are starches.
Activity to test the statement
Materials: diluted iodine solution, a dropper, five small dishes, a slice of potato, some boiled rice, a piece of bread, a spoonful of common sugar dissolved in a little water, and some glucose dissolved in a little water.
Method:
- Place each item on a separate dish and label the dishes.
- With the dropper, put 2–3 drops of diluted iodine solution on each item.
- Keep everything else the same for all the dishes: the same iodine solution, the same number of drops and the same waiting time before observing.
- Observe the colour of each item and record it in a table.
Expected observations:
| Item | Type of carbohydrate | Colour with iodine |
|---|---|---|
| Potato | Starch | Blue-black |
| Boiled rice | Starch | Blue-black |
| Bread | Starch | Blue-black |
| Sugar solution | Sugar (not starch) | No blue-black colour |
| Glucose solution | Glucose (not starch) | No blue-black colour |
Conclusion: a blue-black colour indicates the presence of starch. Potato, rice and bread contain starch, so they turn blue-black. Sugar and glucose are carbohydrates, but they do not turn blue-black, so they are not starches. This supports Raman's statement: all starches are carbohydrates, but not all carbohydrates are starches.
