Charan says that a wooden log is non-living as it cannot move. Charu counters it by saying that it is living because it is made of wood obtained from trees. Give your arguments in favour or against the two statements given by Charan and Charu.
Living Creatures: Exploring their Characteristics · Question 5 of 9
Charan says that a wooden log is non-living as it cannot move.
Charan's statement: Charan is right that the wooden log is non-living, but his reason is wrong. Movement alone cannot decide whether something is living. Plants do not move from one place to another, yet they are living. A car moves on the road, yet it is non-living.
Charu's statement: Charu is wrong. The wood did come from a living tree, but once the tree is cut, the log does not grow, does not respire, does not excrete, does not respond to stimuli and cannot reproduce. When a living being is not able to show these characteristics, even when food, air and water are available, it is said to be dead. So the log is not living now.
Conclusion: the wooden log is non-living, because it does not show the characteristics of living beings, and not just because it cannot move.
