Suppose you are given a chance to repeat the alpha-particle scattering experiment using a thin sheet of solid hydrogen in place of the gold foil. (Hydrogen is a solid at temperatures below 14 K.) What results do you expect?
Atoms · Question 2 of 9
Suppose you are given a chance to repeat the alpha-particle scattering experiment using a thin sheet of solid hydrogen…
Question 23 marksEasy
The nucleus of a hydrogen atom is a single proton, of mass kg, whereas an -particle has a mass of about kg, roughly four times larger.
When a heavy particle collides with a lighter one, it cannot be turned back. It pushes the light particle ahead and carries on, deflected only through a small angle, just as a heavy ball keeps going when it strikes a light one.
So with a hydrogen target:
- the -particles would pass through with only small deflections;
- there would be no large-angle scattering and no back-scattering;
- the protons would be knocked forward instead.
Also, the charge on a proton () is much smaller than that on a gold nucleus (), which further weakens the deflection. The experiment would therefore not reveal the small, massive nucleus. That is why a heavy target such as gold is needed.
