Show that the relation defined in the set of all polygons as
is an equivalence relation. What is the set of all elements in related to the right angle triangle with sides and ?
Confirming your payment
Exercise 1.1 · Question 13 of 16
Show that the relation defined in the set of all polygons as
is an equivalence relation. What is the set of all elements in related to the right angle triangle with sides and ?
For a polygon write for its number of sides, a positive integer with . In this notation
so compares two polygons by one number and nothing else.
Part 1: is an equivalence relationReflexive. For any polygon , , so . Hence is reflexive.
Symmetric. If then , hence and . Hence is symmetric.
Transitive. If and then and , so and . Hence is transitive.
Being reflexive, symmetric and transitive, is an equivalence relation on .
Part 2: the set of all elements related toThe triangle with sides has . So
A polygon has three sides exactly when it is a triangle. Therefore
the set of all elements of related to is the set of all triangles.
Every triangle belongs to it, whatever its size, its side lengths or its angles: equilateral, isosceles and scalene triangles; acute, right-angled and obtuse triangles. No quadrilateral, pentagon or any other polygon belongs to it, because such a polygon has sides, not .
![One large rounded box on a plain background, outlined in blue and titled 'T = every polygon with 3 sides = a
Why "the set of right-angled triangles" is not the answerIt is tempting to notice that , conclude that is right-angled, and then answer "all right-angled triangles". That answer is wrong, and here is the test that settles it.
Let be an equilateral triangle of side . Then , so by the definition of — yet has three angles and is not right-angled. So is in the required set but not in the set of right-angled triangles: the "right-angled" answer leaves out genuine members, and is therefore too small.
The point is that is defined by the number of sides alone. The relation never looks at angles, at side lengths, or at whether two polygons are similar. The facts that happens to be right-angled and happens to have sides are information the relation simply does not use. (For the same reason the triangle with sides , which is not similar to , is nevertheless related to .)