Why are compounds more stable than towards oxidation to their +3 state?
D and F Block Elements · Question 2 of 48
Why are Mn²+ compounds more stable than Fe²+ towards oxidation to their +3 state?
Question 22 marksMedium
Oxidation to the +3 state means removing one more electron, so compare what that electron removal does to each ion.
is . Its five d electrons occupy all five 3d orbitals singly: a half-filled, extra-stable set with maximum exchange energy. Oxidation to () destroys this arrangement, so it is very difficult.
is . Losing one electron gives , , which is the stable half-filled set. So is readily oxidised.

The book's data confirm this:
| Mn | Fe | |
|---|---|---|
| Third ionisation enthalpy () / | 3260 | 2962 |
| / V | +1.57 | +0.77 |
The much more positive for Mn means strongly prefers to go back to .
Hence compounds resist oxidation to the +3 state, while compounds are easily oxidised to .
