Calculate the oxidation number of sulphur, chromium and nitrogen in , and . Suggest structures of these compounds. Account for the fallacy.
Redox Reaction · Question 5 of 30
Calculate the oxidation number of sulphur, chromium and nitrogen in H₂SO₅ , Cr₂O₇²- and NO₃^- .
(a)
Formula method (taking every O as −2):
This is impossible: sulphur has only six valence electrons, so its maximum oxidation number is +6. The fallacy arises because (peroxomonosulphuric acid) contains a peroxide linkage –O–O–, in which each oxygen is −1, not −2.
Structure: . It has three oxygen atoms at −2 (two S=O and one S–OH) and two peroxide oxygen atoms at −1:

(b)
There is no fallacy: chromium has six valence electrons (), so +6 is its maximum oxidation number. The dichromate ion has two tetrahedra sharing one corner oxygen (Cr–O–Cr). It has no peroxide linkage, so all seven oxygen atoms are −2.

(c)
There is no fallacy: nitrogen has five valence electrons, so +5 is its maximum oxidation number. The nitrate ion is trigonal planar, with one N=O and two N–O⁻ bonds in resonance. All three oxygen atoms are −2.

The fallacy: an oxidation number calculated from the formula alone assumes that every oxygen is −2. It gives a wrong value (+8 for S) when the compound contains a peroxide linkage. Only the structure shows how each oxygen is bonded, and so gives the true oxidation number. The negative signs on the singly bonded oxygen atoms in the figures are formal charges, not oxidation numbers.
