(a) Alcoholic KMnO4 is preferred for the following reasons.
- Toluene does not mix with water, but both toluene and KMnO4 dissolve in alcohol. The reaction therefore takes place in one homogeneous phase and is fast.
- In a neutral medium, the reaction itself produces OH− ions (see the equation below). No acid or alkali needs to be added, which saves cost, and the product is obtained as the benzoate, which gives benzoic acid on acidification.
In the reaction, the carbon of the CH3 group changes from −3 to +3 (6 electrons lost per toluene molecule). Mn changes from +7 to +4 (3 electrons gained per MnO4−). Two MnO4− ions are therefore needed per toluene molecule:
C6H5CH3+2MnO4−→C6H5COO−+2MnO2+H2O+OH−
Check: C 7 = 7, H 8 = 8, O 8 = 8, Mn 2 = 2, charge −2 = −2.
(b) Concentrated H2SO4 first displaces the hydrogen halide from both salts:
NaCl+H2SO4→NaHSO4+HCl
NaBr+H2SO4→NaHSO4+HBr
HCl is a weak reducing agent and cannot reduce H2SO4, so colourless HCl gas escapes. HBr is a stronger reducing agent: it reduces sulphuric acid (S: +6 → +4) and is itself oxidised to bromine (Br: −1 → 0), which gives the red vapour:
2HBr+H2SO4→Br2+SO2+2H2O
The difference arises because the reducing power of halide ions increases from Cl− to Br−.