A metal sulphide MS precipitates only if the ionic product after mixing, Qsp=[M2+][S2−], exceeds its Ksp.
Concentrations after mixing (total volume = 10 mL + 5 mL = 15 mL):
[S2−]=1.0×10−19×1510=6.67×10−20 M,[M2+]=0.04×155=1.33×10−2 M
Ionic product (the same for all four metal ions, since all are 0.04 M):
Qsp=(1.33×10−2)(6.67×10−20)=8.89×10−22
| Sulphide | Ksp | Comparison | Precipitate? |
|---|
| FeS | 6.3×10−18 | Qsp<Ksp | No |
| MnS | 2.5×10−13 | Qsp<Ksp | No |
| ZnS | 1.6×10−24 | Qsp>Ksp | Yes |
| CdS | 8.0×10−27 | Qsp>Ksp | Yes |

Precipitation takes place in the ZnCl₂ and CdCl₂ solutions (ZnS and CdS precipitate); FeSO₄ and MnCl₂ give no precipitate. The very low [S2−] in acidic H₂S solution (common-ion effect of HCl) is enough to precipitate only the sulphides with the smallest Ksp.