In Rutherford's experiment, generally the thin foil of heavy atoms, like gold, platinum etc. have been used to be bombarded by the α-particles. If the thin foil of light atoms like aluminium etc. is used, what difference would be observed from the above results?
Structure of Atom · Question 40 of 67
In Rutherford's experiment, generally the thin foil of heavy atoms, like gold, platinum etc.
With a gold foil Rutherford observed that most α-particles passed straight through, a small fraction were deflected through small angles, and a very few (about 1 in 20 000) were deflected through very large angles or bounced back. The large deflections are caused by the strong repulsion between the positive α-particle and the heavy, highly charged nucleus.
With a foil of a light element such as aluminium:
-
The nuclear charge of Al is only compared with for gold, so the repulsion on an α-particle at the same distance is about 6 times weaker. Deflections are therefore much smaller, and large-angle scattering becomes far rarer.
-
The Al nucleus is light (27 u, compared with 197 u for gold), so it recoils noticeably when struck and takes away part of the α-particle's energy. Al is still about 7 times heavier than an α-particle, so back-scattering can occur, but together with the much weaker repulsion it becomes very much rarer (roughly times fewer large-angle deflections).
So almost all α-particles would pass through with little or no deflection. The already rare large-angle deflections, which led Rutherford to conclude that the positive charge and mass are concentrated in a tiny nucleus, would be far fewer, and the nuclear model could not have been inferred so clearly.

