Discuss how classification systems have undergone several changes over a period of time.
Biological Classification · Question 1 of 12
Discuss how classification systems have undergone several changes over a period of time.
1. Early, use-based classification: Since the dawn of civilisation, organisms were classified instinctively, not by scientific criteria, but out of a need to use them for food, shelter and clothing.
2. Aristotle: He was the earliest to attempt a more scientific basis. Using simple morphological characters, he classified plants into trees, shrubs and herbs. He divided animals into two groups: those which had red blood and those that did not.
3. Two kingdom system: In Linnaeus' time, a two kingdom system with Plantae and Animalia was developed. It was easy to use, but it did not distinguish between eukaryotes and prokaryotes, unicellular and multicellular organisms, or photosynthetic (green algae) and non-photosynthetic (fungi) organisms. A large number of organisms did not fall into either kingdom, so the system was found inadequate. A need was felt to include characters besides gross morphology, such as cell structure, nature of wall, mode of nutrition, habitat, methods of reproduction and evolutionary relationships.
4. Problems of the old 'Plants' grouping: Earlier systems placed bacteria, blue green algae, fungi, mosses, ferns, gymnosperms and angiosperms under 'Plants' only because all had a cell wall. This put prokaryotes with eukaryotes, unicellular with multicellular organisms, and heterotrophic fungi (chitin walls) with autotrophic green plants (cellulosic walls).
5. Five kingdom system: R.H. Whittaker (1969) proposed five kingdoms: Monera, Protista, Fungi, Plantae and Animalia. His main criteria were cell structure, body organisation, mode of nutrition, reproduction and phylogenetic relationships. All prokaryotes went into Monera, unicellular eukaryotes into Protista, and fungi into a separate kingdom. Protista brought together Chlamydomonas and Chlorella (earlier algae within Plants) with Paramoecium and Amoeba (earlier in the animal kingdom), because the criteria had changed.
6. Still changing: A three-domain system has also been proposed. It divides Kingdom Monera into two domains and keeps the eukaryotic kingdoms in the third domain, giving a six kingdom classification. Such changes will continue as our understanding of characters and evolutionary relationships improves. The aim is a system that reflects morphological, physiological and reproductive similarities and is also phylogenetic, that is, based on evolutionary relationships.
