Compounds such as alcohols and glucose also contain hydrogen but are not categorised as acids. Describe an activity to prove it.
Acids, Bases and Salts · Question 6 of 15
Compounds such as alcohols and glucose also contain hydrogen but are not categorised as acids.
An acid is not defined by having hydrogen in its formula but by producing hydrogen ions, , in water. Ions carry electric current, so the activity tests whether each solution conducts electricity.
Materials: solutions of glucose and alcohol, dilute hydrochloric acid and dilute sulphuric acid, a 100 mL beaker, a cork with two iron nails fixed in it, a 6 volt battery, a bulb, a switch and connecting wires.
Procedure:
-
Fix two nails on the cork and place the cork in the 100 mL beaker.
-
Connect the nails to the two terminals of the 6 volt battery through the bulb and the switch.
-
Pour some dilute HCl into the beaker so that the nails dip into it, and switch on the current. Note whether the bulb glows.
-
Repeat with dilute sulphuric acid.
-
Repeat separately with the glucose solution and then the alcohol solution, rinsing the beaker in between.

Observation: the bulb glows with dilute HCl and dilute sulphuric acid, but does not glow with the glucose or the alcohol solution.
Conclusion: the acids give ions in water, for example
and these ions carry the current. Glucose and alcohol also contain hydrogen, but they do not separate into ions in water, so there are no ions to carry the current and the bulb stays off. Since it is the ion that makes a substance an acid, compounds such as alcohol and glucose are not categorised as acids.

