(i) Two sounds are heard separately only if they reach us at least 0.1 s apart.
- First echo: 0.70 s after the whistle, and 0.70 s ≥ 0.1 s.
- Second echo: 1.20 s after the whistle, and 1.20 s ≥ 0.1 s.
- Gap between the two echoes: 1.20−0.70=0.50 s, and 0.50 s ≥ 0.1 s.
Every gap is at least 0.1 s, so the whistle and the two echoes are all heard as separate sounds. (1 mark)
(ii) The echo that returns first, after 0.70 s, has the shorter path, so it comes from the nearer cliff.
d1=2v×t=2340 ms−1×0.70 s=119 m
(1 mark)
(iii) Farther cliff:
d2=2340 ms−1×1.20 s=204 m
The shepherd is between the cliffs, so the width of the valley is 119+204=323 m. (1 mark)
The third echo is sound that is reflected by one cliff and then the other before returning. The sound that comes back from the nearer cliff passes the shepherd, goes on to the farther cliff and returns (or the other way round). It travels 2×119+2×204=646 m:
t=340 ms−1646 m=1.9 s
This is simply 0.70+1.20=1.9 s. (1 mark)