(i) Kinetic energy of the arrow: K=21×0.05×402=40 J. By the work-energy theorem, the negative work done by the straw removes all of it:
F×0.2 m=40 J⇒F=0.2 m40 J=200 N
(ii) At 80 ms−1: K=21×0.05×802=160 J, which is 4 times as much. With the same 200 N force,
d=200 N160 J=0.8 m
The student is not right. Doubling the speed makes the kinetic energy 22=4 times larger, so the arrow goes 4 times as deep (0.8 m), not twice as deep.