Aditi is making a calendar puzzle for her younger brother. She writes the proposition
P: "If a month has 31 days, then it is not February."
Which option gives the converse of P together with a correct verdict on the converse?
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 1 of 40
Aditi is making a calendar puzzle for her younger brother. She writes the proposition
P: "If a month has 31 days, then it is not February."
Which option gives the converse of P together with a correct verdict on the converse?
(A) Converse: "If a month is not February, then it has 31 days." It is always true.
(B) Converse: "If a month is not February, then it has 31 days." It is false.
(C) Converse: "If a month is February, then it does not have 31 days." It is always true.
(D) Converse: "If a month does not have 31 days, then it is February." It is false.
Option (B) is correct.
Explanation:
In P, the 'if' part is X: "a month has 31 days", and the 'then' part is Y: "it is not February". The converse swaps them: "If a month is not February, then it has 31 days."
To decide whether the converse is true, look for a month that is not February but does not have 31 days. April has 30 days. April is not February, yet it does not have 31 days, so April is a counterexample and the converse is false. (June, September and November work too.)
P itself is true: February has 28 or 29 days, never 31.
Why the other options are wrong