Ishaan works out two of Mādhava's sums for π:
He says, "If I keep adding terms, these fractions get as close to π as I like. So π itself must be a fraction."
Which statement is correct? (Use to compare.)
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 24 of 40
Ishaan works out two of Mādhava's sums for π:
He says, "If I keep adding terms, these fractions get as close to π as I like. So π itself must be a fraction."
Which statement is correct? (Use to compare.)
(A) Both sums are less than π, so the sums never reach π and so π cannot be a fraction.
(B) π lies between the sums; fractions can get as close as we like to π yet never equal it.
(C) Both sums are greater than π, and since such close fractions exist, π must be a fraction.
(D) π lies between the two sums, and as the sums get as close as we like, π is a fraction.
Option (B) is correct.
Explanation:
Work out each sum with fractions.
Since , π lies between the two sums. Each sum is a fraction (a ratio of two integers), and the sums come closer and closer to π from both sides. But π is irrational (Lambert proved this in 1761): no fraction equals π. Ishaan's reasoning does not work: fractions can come as close as we like to every number, whether it is a fraction or not, so being approached by fractions proves nothing. Fractions can get as close as we like to π without ever equalling it, just as and are close to π but are not π. So Ishaan's claim is wrong.
Why the other options are wrong