Rohit copies the proof that is irrational and tries to use it to “prove” that is irrational. He writes:
Step 1: Suppose , where and are natural numbers with no common factor (lowest terms).
Step 2: Squaring, , so .
Step 3: is even, so is even. Write .
Step 4: Then , so .
Step 5: So is even, and hence is even.
Step 6: Now and are both even, which contradicts Step 1. So is irrational.
(i) Which step is false? Explain why.
(ii) Show directly that is rational.
(iii) Explain why the matching step is correct in the proof for .
