(i) Cutting a square of side x from each corner removes 2x from each side of the card, and the box is x cm tall. So the box is (30−2x) cm long, (20−2x) cm wide and x cm high. For x=5:
V=20×10×5=1000 cm3
(ii) For x=4:
V=22×12×4=1056 cm3
For x=6:
V=18×8×6=864 cm3
As x grows from 4 to 5 to 6, the volume falls from 1056 cm³ to 1000 cm³ to 864 cm³, so it gets smaller. Amit is not right: a bigger square makes the box taller, but it also shrinks the base from both sides.