Option (D) is correct.
Explanation:
The road from B(8, 1) to D(2, 7) passes through the grid points (7, 2), (6, 3), (5, 4), (4, 5) and (3, 6): one km left and one km up each time. Village C(5, 3) lies just below (5, 4), on the same side of BD as A.
So C lies inside △ABD, and the survey road from A ends at C before it reaches BD: the two diagonals AC and BD never meet. A quadrilateral is convex exactly when its diagonals intersect, so ABCD is not convex.
Because C is pushed in towards A, the boundary bends inwards at C: the internal angle at C is more than 180∘ (about 199∘). The dent is at C.

Why the other options are wrong
- (A) Roads that do not cross make ABCD a quadrilateral, but not necessarily a convex one. Convexity needs the diagonals to meet, and here AC and BD do not.
- (B) B is a corner of the triangle ABD that contains C. Its angle is small (about 41∘), not reflex.
- (C) D is also a corner of △ABD. Its angle is about 53∘, not reflex.