Ishaan claims, "Hydrogen atoms in borewell water are lighter than hydrogen atoms in river water."
Which postulate of Dalton's Atomic Theory goes against his claim, and which observation supports that postulate?
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 24 of 40
Ishaan claims, "Hydrogen atoms in borewell water are lighter than hydrogen atoms in river water."
Which postulate of Dalton's Atomic Theory goes against his claim, and which observation supports that postulate?
(A) Atoms cannot be created or destroyed in a chemical reaction — supported by the unchanged reading of a sealed flask of vinegar and baking soda
(B) Atoms combine in the ratio of simple whole numbers — supported by cinnabar always giving about 86.22% mercury and 13.78% sulfur
(C) Atoms of a given element are identical in mass — supported by common salt dissolving in water with no change in mass
(D) Atoms of a given element are identical in mass — supported by purified water from every source having H : O = 1 : 8
Option (D) is correct.
Explanation:
The postulate: Dalton proposed that atoms of a given element are identical in mass and chemical properties. Ishaan's claim says hydrogen atoms from two sources have different masses, so it goes directly against this postulate.
The observation: If borewell hydrogen atoms were lighter, a sample of borewell water would contain less mass of hydrogen for the same mass of oxygen than river water. But purified water from rivers, borewells or the ocean always gives hydrogen and oxygen in the mass ratio 1 : 8. This supports the postulate and goes against Ishaan's claim.
Why the other options are wrong