In a "Chemistry Detective" activity, Ms Banerjee gives her class four white solids, P, Q, R and S, and the results of tests done on them. Each solid was tested for whether it dissolves in water and in petrol, and whether it lets electricity pass as a solid, when melted, and in water. Its melting point was also noted as high or low. The students must decide which solids are ionic and which are covalent.
| Solid | Dissolves in water? | Dissolves in petrol? | Bulb glows with the solid? | Bulb glows with the molten (melted) solid? | Bulb glows with its water solution? | Melting point |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| P | yes | no | no | yes | yes | high |
| Q | no | yes | no | no | does not dissolve | low |
| R | yes | no | no | no | no | low |
| S | no | no | no | yes | does not dissolve | high |
(i) Which of the solids are ionic?
(ii) Why does the bulb not glow with solid P?
(iii) Rishi concludes, "S cannot be ionic, because ionic compounds dissolve in water." Is he right? Use two pieces of evidence from the table to support your answer.
