Confirming your payment

Skip to content

Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 35 of 40

Three students want to test the hypothesis that mass is conserved when magnesium reacts with dilute hydrochloric acid…

Question 353 marksHard

Three students want to test the hypothesis that mass is conserved when magnesium reacts with dilute hydrochloric acid:

Magnesium + Hydrochloric acid (dilute) → Magnesium chloride + Hydrogen

Each student uses 0.96 g of magnesium ribbon and an excess of the acid, and weighs the whole set-up before and after the reaction.

Three set-ups on digital balances: A open beaker, 150.48 g before and 150.40 g after; B flask with a balloon tied on its mouth, 162.36 g before and 162.35 g after; C flask whose rubber cork popped out during the reaction, 155.62 g before and 155.56 g after

(i) Which student's design is suitable for testing the hypothesis? Give a reason.

(ii) What mass of hydrogen was formed in student A's experiment?

(iii) Student B says, "My reading dropped by 0.01 g, so mass is not conserved." Is B right? Also explain why student C's result cannot be used.