In pure methane, C : H = 3 : 1, so carbon is 43 of the mass.
Plant 1: expected carbon =43×4.0 g=3.0 g. Found: 3.0 g. Hydrogen = 4.0 − 3.0 = 1.0 g, so C : H = 3.0 : 1.0 = 3 : 1. Pure methane.
Plant 2: expected carbon =43×6.4 g=4.8 g. Found: only 4.6 g. So carbon is
6.4 g4.6 g≈0.72 of the mass, not 43=0.75
The mass of carbon does not fit the fixed ratio of methane. By the Law of Constant Proportions, every sample of pure methane must have the same ratio, so the gas from plant 2 is not pure methane; it is a mixture containing some other gas.