Aditya says, "Atomic number is the number of electrons in an atom. So if a chlorine atom picks up one extra electron, its atomic number becomes 18 and it turns into argon."
Is Aditya right? Explain, using the definition of atomic number.
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 32 of 40
Aditya says, "Atomic number is the number of electrons in an atom. So if a chlorine atom picks up one extra electron, its atomic number becomes 18 and it turns into argon."
Is Aditya right? Explain, using the definition of atomic number.
(Definition) Aditya is wrong. The atomic number is the number of protons in the nucleus, and it is this number that decides the identity of an element. The number of electrons equals the number of protons only in a neutral atom.
(Applying it) Chlorine has 17 protons. Picking up an electron does not change the nucleus, so it still has 17 protons and its atomic number stays 17: it is still chlorine. It now has 18 electrons and 17 protons, so it carries one extra negative charge (relative charge ) instead of being neutral. Argon would need 18 protons in its nucleus.